Add $35.00 for free shipping
Black Cat Artisan Goods
Maker's Choice — Mystery Bar — photo 1

Surprise me

Maker's Choice — Mystery Bar

★★★★★4.9 · 187 reviews

$8.00

● Made to order · ships in ~2 weeks

We always have one or two bars curing that aren't in the regular lineup yet. Order this and you'll get whatever's freshest — sometimes a one-off scent we'll never make again.

Purchase options
1
  • Palm-Free
  • Small Batch
  • Made in TN

Ingredients

Varies by batch — always saponified plant oils + essentials/botanicals.

Approx. ~4 oz per bar.

Pairs well with

Customer reviews

★★★★★ 4.9 · 187 reviews
★★★★★

"Smells incredible and lasts forever. Won't go back to Dove."

Megan T. · 2026-03
★★★★★

"The charcoal bar is the only thing that's helped my back acne. Bought four more."

Patrick R. · 2026-02
★★★★★

"Honey oat is my favorite — gentle on my eczema and smells like a cozy morning."

Sarah K. · 2026-02

Sample reviews shown — set NEXT_PUBLIC_JUDGEME_SHOP_DOMAIN + NEXT_PUBLIC_JUDGEME_PUBLIC_TOKEN to import real Judge.me reviews.